Serious
Injuries.
Experience.
Results.
When a child suffers a serious injury during labor, delivery, or newborn care, parents may leave the hospital with more questions than answers. A diagnosis such as cerebral palsy, hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, neurological impairment, or another permanent condition can change the course of a child’s life and create substantial medical and caregiving needs for the family.
Snyder & Wenner, P.C. has represented Arizona patients and families in serious medical malpractice cases for more than 40 years. Our attorneys handle complex matters involving catastrophic harm, permanent disability, and wrongful death. Birth injury cases require detailed medical review to identify where the care fell short. The records show what occurred, where providers departed from the accepted standard of care, and how that conduct caused or contributed to the injury.
For families in Mesa, that investigation may involve reviewing prenatal care, labor and delivery records, fetal heart-rate tracings, medications, nursing documentation, physician decisions, newborn treatment, imaging, and later neurological evaluations. When appropriate, we work with qualified medical professionals to assess the care provided and determine whether further legal action may be justified.
Use this form to get the fastest review by an attorney and the fastest response from our office.
Birth injury cases focus on preventable harm: injuries that happen when a provider misses warning signs, delays treatment, or makes decisions that fall below the accepted standard of care.
Childbirth can involve conditions that develop quickly and require physicians, nurses, and other healthcare providers to respond to changing information. When providers fail to recognize those changes or respond in time, the consequences for a baby can be severe. A legal claim generally requires evidence showing that a provider failed to act as a reasonably qualified healthcare provider would have acted under similar circumstances and that this failure caused or contributed to measurable injury.
Each case must be evaluated according to its individual facts.
For example, fetal heart-rate monitoring can provide information about how a baby is tolerating labor. Certain changes may require further evaluation or intervention. If concerning patterns appeared in the record, an investigation may examine when healthcare providers recognized them, how they responded, whether additional steps were indicated, and whether different intervention could have prevented or reduced the resulting harm.
Similar questions arise when a cesarean delivery is delayed. A delayed delivery can become malpractice when the medical evidence shows that earlier delivery was indicated, the healthcare team had enough information to recognize the need for intervention, and the delay affected the child’s condition.
Medical malpractice cases also require proof of causation, meaning evidence that the provider’s conduct probably caused or contributed to the injury. This can involve establishing when the injury occurred, whether the child experienced oxygen deprivation, how long that condition continued, and how timely intervention would have changed the outcome.
The scale of maternal and newborn healthcare throughout the Mesa area provides useful context. According to the Arizona Department of Health Services, Maricopa County recorded 50,161 resident births in 2023. Mesa is one of the county’s largest communities.
Families who suspect that something went wrong do not need to determine on their own whether malpractice occurred. A detailed review of the treatment timeline and medical evidence can help answer that question.
For children with permanent impairments, the investigation must also consider the future. A serious neurological injury may affect mobility, communication, education, employment, independence, and the ability to perform daily activities. Future needs may include physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, medications, mobility equipment, assistive technology, home modifications, attendant care, and ongoing medical treatment.
Evaluating these consequences requires more than calculating existing medical bills. The legal team may need to assess how the injury could affect the child over the course of a lifetime. The parents’ experience also matters because a severe childhood injury can change family responsibilities, work schedules, caregiving demands, and long-term financial planning.
Some birth injuries become apparent immediately. A newborn may require resuscitation, therapeutic cooling, respiratory support, treatment in a neonatal intensive care unit, or neurological testing.
Other conditions become clearer over time.
Parents may begin noticing delayed developmental milestones, muscle stiffness or weakness, problems with balance or coordination, seizures, feeding difficulties, impaired communication, or other neurological concerns. Further testing may eventually identify cerebral palsy, brain damage, or another permanent condition.
A severe birth injury can create needs that continue throughout childhood and adulthood. Depending on the child’s condition, future care may include:
These needs are important when evaluating the consequences of an injury.
A medical malpractice claim involving permanent disability should not be evaluated only by looking at medical expenses already incurred. The analysis may also consider the medical treatment, rehabilitation, caregiving, equipment, and assistance the child is reasonably expected to need over a lifetime.
Future earning capacity may also become relevant when a permanent condition is expected to affect the child’s ability to work independently as an adult.
For parents, these cases often involve more than financial concerns. Families may want to know what happened, whether warning signs were missed, whether the harm could have been prevented, and how they can provide appropriate care for their child in the years ahead.
Those questions deserve clear answers grounded in the medical evidence.
The goal is to understand the practical consequences of the injury throughout the child’s expected lifetime.
Arizona places time limits on medical malpractice actions.
Under A.R.S. § 12-542, an action for injury to another person, including a cause of action for medical malpractice, generally must be commenced within two years after the cause of action accrues.
Birth injury matters require additional consideration because the injured child is a minor. A.R.S. § 12-502 provides that when a person entitled to bring certain actions is under 18 at the time the claim accrues, the period of that disability is not counted as part of the applicable limitations period.
That does not mean every claim connected to a child’s birth necessarily follows the same deadline. Parents may have separate claims, and other circumstances can affect the time available to take legal action.
Families should therefore obtain guidance based on their individual circumstances rather than assume that a general deadline applies.
Reviewing the matter sooner can have practical benefits as well. Medical records can be requested, important events can be documented, and the treatment timeline can be examined while information remains available.
If your child suffered a serious injury during labor, delivery, or newborn care in Mesa, Snyder & Wenner can review the medical circumstances and explain whether the evidence supports further investigation.
Hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, often called HIE, is a type of brain injury associated with inadequate oxygen and blood flow to the brain. When HIE develops during labor or delivery, records may be examined to determine whether providers missed signs of oxygen deprivation or delayed treatment that could have prevented or reduced the injury.
Fetal monitoring records can document changes in the baby’s heart rate throughout labor. These records may help establish when concerning patterns appeared, how providers interpreted those patterns, and what interventions were taken in response.
It may when medical evidence demonstrates that an earlier delivery was indicated, healthcare providers failed to act appropriately, and the delay caused or contributed to serious harm. A review of the labor timeline can show when the need for delivery became clear and how long providers took to respond.
Depending on the evidence, potentially responsible parties may include physicians, nurses, hospitals, healthcare organizations, or other providers involved in labor, delivery, and newborn care. Responsibility is determined by examining each provider’s role and conduct.
Evidence may include prenatal records, fetal heart-rate tracings, nursing documentation, physician notes, medication records, laboratory results, delivery records, operative reports, neonatal intensive care records, imaging, and subsequent neurological or developmental evaluations.
Depending on the circumstances, recoverable damages may address medical treatment, rehabilitation, therapy, medications, equipment, caregiver assistance, home modifications, reduced earning capacity, and other consequences of permanent disability. The losses available in any case depend on the evidence.
Our attorneys begin by learning what happened and identifying the records necessary to evaluate the care provided. When appropriate, we work with qualified medical professionals to assess the treatment timeline, applicable standard of care, causation, and long-term consequences. We then explain what the evidence indicates and whether additional legal investigation may be warranted.